PA & PHILLY LAWS, PLUS DIRECTIVES
BUSINESS: Every business, tenant, and property owner has the 'legal right' to keep their sidewalks clear of loiterers at any time, no restrictions. In Philadelphia, under Title 9, businesses have the ‘right and responsibility’ to keep the vicinity around their business free from “prohibited conduct” as defined under Title 10. Under Title 9, businesses that allow prohibited conduct on the sidewalk or street, as defined under Title 10, can be forced to remediate the situation or be closed down. Unfortunately, most businesses don't know about Title 9, and believe that they have no rights or responsibilities to forbid prohibited conduct on their sidewalk or street. Even businesses who have security staff, often do not allow them to enforce security outside of the building, in violation of Title 9. This is a situation that SafeStreetsPhilly has tried to remediate through educating the various businesses, but it would be better handled by the city disseminating this information to the public.
CHAPTER 9-4400. RESPONSIBLE BUSINESS OPERATIONS https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/philadelphia/latest/philadelphia_pa/0-0-0-280674
CHAPTER 10-600. PUBLIC PLACES – PROHIBITED CONDUCT https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/philadelphia/latest/philadelphia_pa/0-0-0-282124#JD_Chapter10-600
"Prohibited Conduct" under Title 10 (not the complete list):
more info below
RESEARCH, NEWS, & ISSUES:
Two anti-Safe Injection Sights legislation which we support - Please attend the May 25, 2023, City Council meeting, City Hall, Room 400, 10:00 am. Please come prepared to speak. There’s a sign-up sheet in the hallway. You may not get more than 2 minutes. It's best to write out what you want to say – about 320 words – and speak clearly, because the acoustics are horrible in that room. Hope to see you there. Lynn Landes 714-204-2690
Article: "Philly City Council members move to ban supervised injection sites in about half the city" - https://www.inquirer.com/politics/philadelphia/philly-safe-injection-site-city-council-20230511.html
May 11, 2023: Resolution 230432: Calling on Safehouse, the United States Department of Justice, and the Mayor to halt implementation of supervised injection sites in the City of Philadelphia, to involve community groups and other branches of city government with differing views to participate in settlement negotiations, and to enforce the previous holding from the Third Circuit Court of Appeals. Sponsors: Councilmember Harrity, Councilmember Lozada, Councilmember Driscoll, Councilmember Squilla, Councilmember O'Neill, Councilmember Bass, Councilmember Vaughn https://phila.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=6203827&GUID=0DC47801-199C-4DD0-9245-562CB0A44B63&Options=ID%7CText%7C&Search=&FullText=1
May, 11, 2023: Bill No. 230410: Amending Chapter 14-500 of The Philadelphia Code entitled, "Overlay Zoning Districts," to add an overlay district pertaining to injection sites for narcotics, all under certain terms and conditions. Councilmember Lozada, Councilmember Driscoll, Councilmember Squilla, Councilmember Harrity, Councilmember O'Neill, Councilmember Johnson, Councilmember Bass, Councilmember Vaughn https://phila.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=6203800&GUID=F5DFE06F-DAA4-4EFA-9F41-E60A1AD68408&Options=ID|Text|&Search=
In the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, property owners and
tenants have the absolute legal right to keep their sidewalks clear of criminal
behavior and prohibited conduct (i.e., loitering, panhandling, homeless, etc.):
PA Code, Title 18 - CRIMES AND OFFENSES
https://law.justia.com/codes/pennsylvania/2019/title-18
Chapter 35 - Burglary and Other Criminal Intrusion
https://law.justia.com/codes/pennsylvania/2019/title-18/chapter-35
Section 3503
– Criminal and Defiant Trespass.
https://law.justia.com/codes/pennsylvania/2019/title-18/chapter-35/section-3503
or
https://www.legis.state.pa.us/WU01/LI/LI/CT/HTM/18/00.035.003.000..HTM
In Philadelphia, under Title 9, businesses have the ‘right and responsibility’ to keep the vicinity around their business (sidewalks and streets) free from “prohibited conduct” as defined under Title 10. Under Title 9, businesses that allow prohibited conduct on the sidewalk or street, as defined under Title 10, can be forced to remediate the situation or be closed down. Unfortunately, most businesses don't know about Title 9, and believe that they have no rights or responsibilities to forbid prohibited conduct on their sidewalk or street.
PHILADELPHIA CODE:
CHAPTER 9-4400. RESPONSIBLE BUSINESS OPERATIONS https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/philadelphia/latest/philadelphia_pa/0-0-0-280674
CHAPTER 10-600. PUBLIC PLACES – PROHIBITED CONDUCT https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/philadelphia/latest/philadelphia_pa/0-0-0-282124#JD_Chapter10-600
§ 10-603. Loitering. 126(1) Definitions.(a) Loitering. Idling or lounging in or about any place or facility described in (2), so as to prevent others from passage, ingress or egress, or to idle or lounge in or about any place or facility described in (2) in violation of any existing statutes or ordinances(b) Private Property Used to Accommodate the Public. Any building, structure, equipment or other thing, including the land upon which it is situate, abutting premises that are used incidentally for the accommodation of the public, including the sidewalks and streets adjacent thereto.(2) Prohibited Conduct. No person shall loiter in, on or about any underground platform or concourse, or any elevated platform serving public transportation facilities, or any underground or elevated passageway used by the public, or any railroad or railway passenger station or platform, or on the steps leading to any of them. No person shall loiter in, on or about private property used to accommodate the public. 127(3) Duties of Persons Controlling Private Property Used to Accommodate the Public. The owner, lessee, manager or other person in control of any real estate which is used to accommodate the public shall ask any person violating this Section to voluntarily correct the violation and if the violator neglects or refuses to correct his violation shall make a report immediately to the Police Department and cooperate with the police in removing any violator from the private property used to accommodate the public.(4) This Section shall not apply to any picketing or other incidental activities of a labor union in a labor dispute governed by:(a) The Pennsylvania Labor Relations Act of 1937 as amended.(b) The Labor Anti-Injunction Act of 1937 as amended.(c) The Public Employees Relations Act (1970).(d) The Labor Management Relations Act of 1947 as amended.
§ 10-611. Sidewalk Behavior (6) https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/philadelphia/latest/philadelphia_pa/0-0-0-282124#JD_Chapter10-600 Maintenance of the Sidewalk by Private Property Owners. (a) The owner and the occupier of any private property shall keep the abutting sidewalk free of any litter, snow, or other obstructions, pursuant to Sections 10-704, 10-714 and 10-720.
§ 10-611. Sidewalk Behavior. 139(1) Scope. The provisions of this Section shall apply as follows:(a) The following provisions shall apply city-wide: subsections (2)(a), relating to parking a motorized vehicle on the sidewalk; (2)(b), relating to gambling on the sidewalk; (2)(f), relating to unlicensed sale of goods or services on the sidewalk; (2)(i), relating to the sale of goods or services, or solicitation of funds, on the highway; (2)(j), relating to displaying for sale objectionable material; (2)(l), relating to unreasonable obstructions on the sidewalk; (5)(a), relating to honor boxes on the sidewalk without a permit; (5)(b), relating to littering on the sidewalk; (5)(c), relating to excessive noise on the sidewalk; (6)(a), relating to owner/occupier of private property keeping the sidewalk clear of litter and obstructions; and (6)(b), relating to owner/occupier of private property keeping the sidewalk in good repair.(b) The following provisions shall apply only in the zones designated by Council: (2)(c), relating to riding a bicycle on the sidewalk; (2)(d), relating to riding a scooter, roller skates or skateboard on the sidewalk; (2)(e), relating to loading or unloading a commercial vehicle on the sidewalk; (2)(g), relating to lying on the sidewalk; (2)(h), relating to sitting on the sidewalk; (2)(k), relating to unlicensed placement of any bench, planter, fixture or street furniture on the sidewalk; (2)(m), relating to unattended belongings on the sidewalk; (2)(n), relating to unrestrained animals on the sidewalk; (4)(a), (b) and (c), relating to aggressive solicitation; and (6)(c), relating to owner of take-out restaurants care of trash receptacles on the sidewalk. 140(c) The provisions identified in subsection (b) above shall apply in the following designated zones only:(.1) The area bounded by the north side of Vine street on the north, the west side of Broad street on the east, the south side of Lombard street on the south, and the Schuylkill River on the west.(.2) Broad street, from the south side of City Hall-South to the Philadelphia Naval Business Center.(.3) South street, from the west side of Broad street to the Schuylkill River.(.4) Washington avenue, from the west side of Broad street to Grays Ferry avenue.(.5) Grays Ferry avenue, from Washington avenue to Forty-ninth street.(.6) Woodland avenue from Fifty-eighth street to Seventy-fourth street.(.7) Passyunk avenue, from Broad street to Sixty-third street.(.8) Essington avenue, from Sixty-third street to the Bartram Avenue Airport District.(.9) The First Councilmanic District.(.10) The Sixth Councilmanic District.(.11) The area bounded by the Schuylkill River on the east running west on Spring Garden street to Fortieth street, then south to Market street, then west to Fifty-second street, then south to Woodland avenue, then east to University avenue, then south to the Schuylkill River. 141(.12) The Seventh Councilmanic District. 142(.13) The Fourth Councilmanic District. 143(2) Obstructing the Sidewalk Prohibited. No person shall:(a) Park any motorized vehicle on the public sidewalk.(b) Conduct any gambling or other games of chance on the public sidewalk.(c) Ride a bicycle upon any public sidewalk, subject to the provisions of Chapter 12-800. 144(d) Ride a scooter, roller skates or skateboard on any public sidewalk.(e) Obstruct the public sidewalk while loading or unloading a commercial or other vehicle, except as shall be necessary for the safe and expeditious loading or unloading of such vehicle.(f) Sell or offer for sale any goods, wares or services on the public sidewalk, without a license from the Department of Licenses and Inspections pursuant to Chapter 9-200.(g) Lie on the public sidewalk, or on any object placed on the public sidewalk.(h) Sit on the public sidewalk, or on any object placed on the public sidewalk, for more than one hour in any two hour time period.(i) Sell or offer for sale any goods, wares or services, or solicit funds for any purpose, in or on the public highway, except for licensed vendors.(.1) If the Department of Licenses and Inspections determines, in its discretion, that particular locations or particular vending or solicitation activities do not present a safety hazard to either the vendor or solicitor or the public, the Department may issue regulations permitting such activities and/or activities at certain designated locations, subject to such restrictions as the Department deems necessary to protect the vendor or solicitor and the public from unnecessary hazards.(j) Display for sale any objectionable material, as defined in Section 10-1301, if such objectionable material may be visible by pedestrians on or from the public sidewalk.(k) Place or maintain any bench, planter, fixture or other street furniture on the public sidewalk without a permit from the Department of Licenses and Inspections.(.1) The Department of Licenses and Inspections shall issue regulations setting forth the standards for such permit issuance, which standards shall insure that such street furniture does not obstruct the free passage of the sidewalks, and shall insure that such street furniture is maintained and situated in such manner as to promote a safe and attractive sidewalk environment. The permit requirement set forth in this subsection shall not become effective until such regulations are in effect.(.2) Mechanical vending boxes for the distribution of newspapers or other printed material shall not be subject to the provisions of this subsection.(l) Sit, stand, lie or otherwise use the public sidewalk, or place one's belongings or other objects upon the public sidewalk, in such manner as to unreasonably and significantly impede or obstruct the free passage of pedestrians.(m) Allow his or her belongings or other objects to remain unattended on the public sidewalk for more than fifteen minutes.(n) Allow any dogs, guard cats, pigs or snakes on the public sidewalk unless properly restrained by leash or, in the case of snakes, in a cage.(.1) Any animal with a known vicious propensity shall be muzzled.(3) Exceptions.(a) The prohibitions set forth in subsections (2)(g) and (2)(h), relating to sitting or lying, shall not apply to any person sitting or lying due to a medical emergency.(b) The prohibitions set forth in subsection (2)(h), relating to sitting, shall not apply to any person:(.1) Who requires the use of a wheelchair or other similar device to move about the sidewalk.(.2) Operating or patronizing a commercial establishment properly licensed for business on the public sidewalk.(.3) Participating in or attending a properly permitted parade, procession or assemblage under Section 12-1109.(.4) Sitting on a chair or bench supplied by a public agency, for a period not to exceed six hours in any twenty-four hour period.(.5) Sitting on a chair supplied by the abutting property owner.(.6) Sitting within a transit stop, waiting for public or private transportation.(c) The prohibitions set forth in subsections (2)(c) and (d), relating to bicycles, scooters, roller skates and skateboards, shall not apply to any person under the age of twelve (12). Nor shall it apply to any person on inline skates who is (a) conducting patrol under a Town Watch program coordinated with the Police Department; (b) participating in an International Inline Skating Association sanctioned event; or (c) skating in a controlled manner on the public sidewalk so as to fit in with the flow of pedestrians.(4) Aggressive Conduct on the Sidewalk Prohibited. No person shall: 145(a) Solicit money for any purpose on the public sidewalk in an aggressive manner, or accompanied by conduct, including but not limited to repeated begging, insistent panhandling, retaliatory comments, blockage of free passage of a pedestrian, touching or yelling at a pedestrian, confrontation or intimidation, which is likely to cause a reasonable person to fear bodily harm to oneself or another, or damage to or loss of property.(b) Solicit money for any purpose on the public sidewalk in any manner, within an eight foot (8') radius of any building entrance, or within an eight foot (8') radius of any vending cart.(c) Solicit money for any purpose on the public sidewalk in any manner, within a twenty foot (20') radius of any bank entrance or any automatic teller machine.(5) Cluttering the Sidewalk Prohibited. No person shall:(a) Place or maintain any newspaper or other mechanical vending box on the public sidewalk without a permit from the Department of Licenses and Inspections.(.1) The Department of Licenses and Inspections shall issue regulations setting forth the standards for such permit issuance, which standards shall insure that such boxes do not obstruct the free passage of the sidewalks, and shall insure that such boxes are maintained and situated in such manner as to promote a safe and attractive sidewalk environment. The permit requirement set forth in this subsection shall not become effective until such regulations are in effect and in no event before January 1, 1999. If City Council should enact another ordinance regulating the placement and maintenance of such boxes on the public sidewalk, such ordinance shall supersede the requirements of this subsection (a).(b) Place any litter on the public sidewalk, as set forth in Chapter 10-700.(c) Produce or allow the discharge of excessive noise, from whatever source, on the public sidewalk, as set forth in Chapter 10-400.(6) Maintenance of the Sidewalk by Private Property Owners.(b) The owner of any private property shall keep the abutting public sidewalk in good repair, at the owner's expense.(c) The owner of any business, a substantial portion of which business's revenues derive from take-out food or beverages, shall place, maintain and keep clean private trash receptacles on the public sidewalk at all public entrances to such business.
(7) Enforcement.
(a) Except as set forth in subsection 10-611(7)(e), no law enforcement officer shall issue a notice of violation or take any coercive action against any person in violation of this Section, unless, prior to issuing such notice or taking such action, the officer or his or her designated representative: 146(.1) With respect to violations of subsections (2)(g), (h), (l) or (m), relating to lying, sitting, obstructing, or leaving objects unattended, or (4)(b) or (c), relating to soliciting near a building entrance or bank, first issues an oral warning to the person or persons in violation, and then, if the person or persons refuse to comply after receiving an oral warning, issues a written warning to the person or persons in violation. The written warning shall be printed in English and Spanish. 147(.2) With respect to violations of subsections (2)(g), (h), (l) or (m), or (4), attempts to ascertain whether the person is in need of medical assistance or social service assistance, including but not limited to mental health treatment, drug or alcohol rehabilitation, or homeless assistance services; and, if the officer determines that the person may be in need of social service assistance, the officer contacts an Outreach Team, who shall come to the officer's location, evaluate the person's needs, and together with the officer take all reasonable steps toward directing the person to the appropriate service provider, including but not limited to offering transportation to such provider. If the officer's reasonable efforts to direct the person to needed social services are unsuccessful, the officer may issue a notice of violation or take appropriate coercive action, after the required notice is given, subject to compliance with subsections (.a), (.b) and (.c), below.(.a) In attempting to ascertain whether social service assistance is needed, the officer or his or her designated representative shall:(i) Whenever the officer has reason to believe the person may be in need of social service assistance, call upon an Outreach Team to evaluate the person's needs.(ii) Shall not take any coercive action, including but not limited to compelling a person to reveal any confidential information concerning treatment or mental health status.(.b) No law enforcement officer shall attempt to forcibly remove any person from the public sidewalk for violation of subsections (2)(g), (h), (l) or (m), or (4) without the presence of an Outreach Team, whenever the officer determines that the person may be in need of mental health or other social service assistance, and without first making all reasonable efforts to place the person voluntarily in an appropriate social service facility or treatment facility and the availability of an appropriate residential facility with appropriate treatment strategies for the client's needs.(.c) If the law enforcement officer, in consultation with the Mental Health Officer, determines that the person, because of his or her mental health status or otherwise, presents a danger to himself or herself or to others, the law enforcement officer shall take such steps as are authorized under the Mental Health Procedures Act, Act of July 9, 1976, P.L. 817, as amended, including, if necessary, the initiation of involuntary commitment proceedings.(b) The Police Department shall take all necessary and appropriate steps to insure that law enforcement officers who are likely to come into contact with persons in violation of subsections (2)(b), (g), (h), (l) or (m), or (4) shall receive all appropriate training in approaching, investigating and assisting persons in need of mental health treatment or other social service assistance.(c) Violations of subsection (2)(a), relating to parking vehicles on the sidewalk, shall be enforced in accordance with the provisions set forth in Chapter 12-2800.(d) For purposes of this Section, an Outreach Team shall mean a group of mental health or drug and alcohol counselors authorized and designated by the Department of Public Health to provide access to residential treatment for homeless persons with mental health diagnoses and/or drug and alcohol complications.(8) Penalties. A person found in violation of this Section shall be subject to penalty, as follows:(a) For a violation of subsections (2)(a), relating to parking a motorized vehicle on the sidewalk; (2)(b), relating to gambling on the sidewalk; (2)(g), relating to lying on the sidewalk; (2)(d), relating to riding a scooter, roller skates or skateboard on the sidewalk; (2)(h), relating to sitting 149 on the sidewalk; (2)(l), relating to unreasonable obstructions on the sidewalk; and (2)(m), relating to unattended belongings on the sidewalk, a fine of twenty dollars ($20). 150(b) For a violation of subsections (4)(a), (b) and (c), relating to aggressive solicitation, a fine of not more than one hundred dollars ($100).(c) For a violation of subsections (2)(i), relating to the sale of goods or services, or solicitation of funds, on the highway; (2)(j), relating to displaying for sale objectionable material; (2)(n), relating to unrestrained animals on the sidewalk; (5)(b), relating to littering on the sidewalk; (6)(a), relating to owner/occupier of private property keeping the sidewalk clear of litter and obstructions; and (6)(c), relating to owner of take-out restaurants care of trash receptacles on the sidewalk, a minimum fine of one hundred dollars ($100) and no more than three hundred dollars ($300).(d) For a violation of subsections (2)(e), relating to loading or unloading a commercial vehicle on the sidewalk; (2)(f), relating to unlicensed sale of goods or services on the sidewalk; (2)(k), relating to unlicensed placement of any bench, planter, fixture or street furniture on the sidewalk; (5)(a), relating to honor boxes on the sidewalk without a permit; and (6)(b), relating to owner/occupier of private property keeping the sidewalk in good repair, a fine of not more than three hundred dollars ($300). 151(e) For a violation of subsection (5)(c), relating to excessive noise on the sidewalk, fines as follows:(.1) for the first violation, a fine of not less than twenty-five dollars ($25) and not more than three hundred dollars ($300);(.2) for the second violation, a fine of not less than one hundred dollars ($100) and not more than three hundred dollars ($300); and(.3) for the third and subsequent violations, fines of not less than three hundred dollars ($300).(f) Each day a violation of this Section continues shall constitute a separate violation.(g) In all cases, the court, in its discretion, may suspend the fine upon agreement by the offender to perform such community service or to participate in such social service assistance program or rehabilitation program as the City recommends and the court deems appropriate. No person shall be imprisoned for violating this Section or for failing to pay a fine for violating this Section.(9) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Section, nothing in this Section shall apply in the Third Councilmanic District, except for the area bounded by the Schuylkill River on the East running West on Spring Garden street to Fortieth street, then South to Market street, then West to Fifty-second street, then South to Woodland avenue, then East to University avenue, then South to the Schuylkill River, which area shall be subject to all provisions of this Section, including, but not limited to, subsection 10-611(1)(a), relating to provisions applying citywide, and subsection 10-611(1)(b), relating to provisions applying in designated zones. 154
(a) Persons 14 through 17 years of age may be subject to involuntary emergency examination and treatment only in an approved mental health facility capable of providing a treatment program appropriate to the person. Persons 5 through 13 years of age may be subject to involuntary emergency examination and treatment only in an approved mental health facility capable of providing a treatment program appropriate to the child. Persons from birth through 4 years of age may be subject to involuntary emergency examination and treatment only in a mental health facility capable of providing a treatment program appropriate to the child. Should no such facility exist within the county of residence, the nearest appropriate facility shall be designated by the county administrator. Longer term involuntary treatment for the age groups listed in this section, must be conducted by agencies with age appropriate programs which are approved by the Department and designated by the county administrator when public monies are utilized for treatment.
(b) Persons 18 years of age and older may be subject to involuntary emergency examination at an approved facility designated for such purpose by the administrator. Involuntary emergency treatment may be provided at the examining facility or any other designated and approved facility appropriate to the person’s needs. Travel arrangements between the examining facility and the treating facility shall be arranged as needed as soon as possible to permit transportation appropriate to the person’s needs.0.
(c) The determination of whether the standards of clear and present danger are met should always include a consideration of the person’s probable behavior if adequate treatment is not provided on either an emergency or subsequent basis.
(d) The standards of clear and present danger may be met when a person has made a threat of harm to self or others; has made a threat to commit suicide; or has made a threat to commit an act of mutilation and has committed acts in furtherance of any such threats.
(e) Examining physicans should consider the probability that the person would be unable without care, supervision, and the continued assistance of others, to satisfy his need for nourishment, personal or medical care, shelter or self-protection, and safety in accordance with section 301(b)(2)(i) of the act (50 P. S. § 7301(b)(2)(i)).
(f) When the petition for commitment filed under section 301(b)(2)(i) alleges that a person poses a clear and present danger to himself, clinical or other testimony may be considered which demonstrates that the person’s judgment and insight is so severely impaired that he or she is engaging in uncontrollable behavior which is so grossly irrational or grossly inappropriate to the situation that such behavior prevents him from satisfying his need for reasonable nourishment, personal care, medical care, shelter or self-protection and safety, and that serious physical debilitation, serious bodily injury or death may occur within 30 days unless adequate treatment is provided on an involuntary basis.
(g) An attempt under sections 301(b)(2)(ii) and (iii) of the act (50 P. S. § 7301(b)(2)(ii) and (iii)), occurs:
(1) When a person clearly articulates or demonstrates an intention to commit suicide or mutilate himself and has committed an overt action in furtherance of the intended action; or
(2) When the person has actually performed such acts.
Jury Instructions
Although the court did not charge the jury on these regulations which specify that a suicide attempt consists of an intent to commit suicide and an overt act in furtherance of the intended action, there was no error because 50 P. S. § 7301 fully and accurately conveyed the applicable law. Mertz v. Temple University Hospital, 25 Pa. D & C 4th 541 (Pa.) (1995).
Suicide
The writing of suicide notes can be considered an overt act in furtherance of a suicide. Mertz v. Temple University Hospital, 25 Pa. D & C 4th 541 (Pa.) (1995).
A psychiatrist who discharged a patient brought to a hospital’s psychiatric emergency room for involuntary commitment under the Mental Health Procedures Act (50 P. S. § § 7101—7503), was held liable to three minors injured when the patient blew up a row house while committing suicide. Mertz v. Temple University Hospital, 25 Pa. D & C 4th 541 (Pa.) (1995).